Skip to content

ExplainerHealthCalifornia3 min read

What a brain-tumor discovery means for healthy adults considering full-body MRI

Following a high-profile brain tumor discovery, medical groups continue to advise healthy adults against routine full-body MRI screenings.

Share

Topics

Large circular MRI scanner in a clean clinical room with a sliding blue patient table ready for imaging

REDWOOD CITY, Calif., July 21 (San Francisco News Online) — A report that a preventive scan found a brain tumor has put full-body MRI back in the spotlight. But for most healthy adults, the medical bottom line has not changed: major U.S. groups do not recommend whole-body MRI as routine screening for people without symptoms or specific risk factors.

The Food and Drug Administration says it knows of no scientific evidence that scanning people without symptoms does more good than harm. The American College of Radiology says there is not enough evidence to recommend total-body screening for patients with no symptoms, risk factors or family history suggesting disease or serious injury. The American Academy of Family Physicians and the American College of Preventive Medicine also recommend against using whole-body scans to look for early tumors in people who are not sick.

What full-body MRI is supposed to do

Full-body MRI is marketed as a way to look for hidden problems early, including cancer and heart disease. CBS San Francisco reported that Prenuvo promotes its scan as a way to detect more than 500 conditions, including early-stage tumors.

The attraction is easy to understand. MRI does not use ionizing radiation, unlike CT scans, the American Cancer Society says. That makes it different from many other imaging tests. But lower radiation exposure does not automatically mean better screening.

Why doctors are cautious

The main concern is that a scan can find things that look suspicious but turn out not to matter. The American Cancer Society says the downside can be the “downstream effects” — more tests, more procedures and more worry. It also says whole-body scans can show “spots” or “shadows” that may be normal variations in the body.

Dr. Rebecca Smith-Bindman, a UCSF radiology researcher quoted by CBS San Francisco, said there is “not a stitch of evidence” that the scans help people live longer or better. She also warned that there could be “tremendous numbers of false positives,” meaning test results that look alarming but do not point to real disease.

That problem is one reason the test is not part of standard preventive care. The American Cancer Society says insurance companies rarely pay for whole-body MRIs because they are not considered routine medical care. The Cleveland Clinic says the scan can also lead to overdiagnosis, when doctors find something that would not have caused symptoms or death, and it can still miss problems, which can create false reassurance.

What the brain-tumor story changes — and what it does not

Fox News reported that a former “Bachelor” contestant said a preventive scan found a brain tumor before symptoms appeared. Stories like that can make the test seem more appealing. But doctors say one dramatic case does not answer the bigger question: whether screening large numbers of healthy people actually improves health overall.

A JAMA editorial by Matthew Davenport of the University of Michigan and Dr. Scott Reeder said no major medical group recommends whole-body MRI for the general population because the benefits are still unproven. ABC News reported that the editorial warned that positive scans can lead to more testing and stress, and that the harms can come from invasive follow-up procedures or surgeries of uncertain benefit.

For readers in San Francisco, the local angle is clear. UCSF is part of the Bay Area conversation, and its experts are among those warning that a scan finding is not the same as proof that routine screening works. The issue is not whether full-body MRI can ever find a serious problem. It can. The real question, according to the FDA and multiple medical groups, is whether screening healthy people with no symptoms helps enough to outweigh the risk of false alarms, extra tests and cost.

Share

Topics

Sheyna Greenamyer

Sheyna Greenamyer is a senior California reporter for Times Media Service, based in Sacramento, California, covering health and religion. Greenamyer reports on health developments and on faith and religious life in communities across California, focusing on the people and issues behind the headlines. Greenamyer holds a master's degree in communications and grew up in Long Beach, California.

Write to Sheyna