Duckworth demands TSA reverse ‘shoes-on’ policy after classified report flags airport security vulnerability
Sen. Tammy Duckworth is demanding the TSA reinstate the pre-2025 shoes-off screening after a classified DHS OIG review found Advanced Imaging Technology scanners may miss threats hidden in footwear, calling the shoes-on policy an unacceptable security vulnerability.
Key takeaways
- Sen. Tammy Duckworth urged Acting TSA Administrator Ha Nguyen McNeill to restore the pre-2025 shoes-off rule for screening.
- DHS OIG red-team testing reportedly found Advanced Imaging Technology scanners do not reliably detect items concealed in shoes, flagged in a seven-day notice.
- Duckworth accuses then-DHS Secretary Kristi Noem of implementing the shoes-on policy recklessly and possibly without meaningful TSA consultation.
- Legal concern: Duckworth says DHS missed a required 90-day deadline to outline corrective actions, raising possible federal law violations.
Details of the OIG findings and urgency
Duckworth’s demand follows reporting that a covert Department of Homeland Security Office of Inspector General (OIG) red-team test showed Advanced Imaging Technology scanners failed to detect threats concealed in footwear. The OIG used a seven-day notice to flag the problem as an imminent threat to safety or operations.
Red-team testing is conducted covertly to assess real-world detection capability. According to reporting, inspectors placed test items inside shoes and found scanners could miss those items — the same concern that led to the original shoes-off practice after the 2001 shoe bomber attempt.
Duckworth’s letter: accusations and legal questions
In a sharply worded letter to Acting TSA Administrator Ha Nguyen McNeill, Duckworth called Noem’s decision a “reckless act” that “betrays TSA’s mission.” She said allowing the security gap to persist for months without corrective action was “outrageous, unacceptable and dangerous.”
“Allowing the security gap to remain for seven months without corrective action was outrageous, unacceptable and dangerous,” Duckworth wrote, noting DHS missed a legally required 90-day deadline to outline corrective steps.
Duckworth, the ranking member of the Commerce, Science and Transportation Subcommittee, framed the failure as both a technical and moral lapse — arguing leadership must put safety ahead of convenience and political priorities.
Kristi Noem’s rationale and the administrative context
Noem announced the shoes-on policy on July 8, 2025, saying it would reduce wait times and speed passenger throughput. Proponents argued the change would modernize screening and improve the travel experience, while critics — including Duckworth — say operational efficiency cannot come at the cost of a security gap.
Reports indicate the change may have been pushed without sufficient TSA buy-in. Duckworth urged immediate withdrawal of the policy and restoration of shoe removal at checkpoints until screening can be proven effective.
TSA and DHS response so far
As of the latest reporting, TSA and current DHS leadership had not publicly reversed the shoes-on policy or issued a detailed response to Duckworth’s letter. CBS News first reported on the classified audit and the broader vulnerabilities, which prompted the senator’s public call to action.
Local outlets covered Duckworth’s demand: NBC Chicago and WGN ran video segments on the issue.
Security history and stakes
The shoes-off practice dates to the 2001 shoe bomber attempt, a low-cost, widely accepted measure to reduce risk. The current debate centers on whether Advanced Imaging Technology can safely replace shoe removal and whether the technology in use actually does the job.
What critics and supporters say
Supporters of the shoes-on policy emphasize speed and convenience, arguing modern screening should allow shoes to remain on. Critics, led by Duckworth, say the classified OIG findings show the technology is not ready and that the policy is therefore premature and dangerous.
The core dispute: can OIG-flagged deficiencies be fixed quickly with upgrades or procedures, or should TSA revert to shoes-off screening until scanners are proven reliable?
