Maxwell Pleads the Fifth in Brief House Deposition; Attorney Says She’ll Talk Only If Trump Grants Clemency
Ghislaine Maxwell invoked her Fifth Amendment right during a brief virtual deposition before the House Oversight Committee on Feb. 9, 2026; her attorney says she’ll only testify if President Donald Trump grants clemency, intensifying scrutiny of the probe.
- Maxwell refused to answer questions in a closed-door virtual deposition that lasted under an hour; her lawyer asserted her Fifth Amendment right (ABC News).
- Attorney David Oscar Markus said Maxwell has no evidence implicating Presidents Trump or Bill Clinton and would speak only if granted clemency by Mr. Trump (CBS News).
- The deposition is part of a bipartisan House Oversight probe launched after a July 2025 subpoena; the committee plans more depositions and transparency measures (Politico live updates).
What happened in the deposition
The virtual session lasted less than an hour. Committee staff began the closed-door interview on Monday morning, and Maxwell’s attorney promptly asserted her client’s right against self-incrimination. Maxwell declined to answer questions and the interview ended without testimony, according to multiple reports (ABC News; CBS News).
Why her attorney said she would remain silent
David Oscar Markus read an opening statement explaining why Maxwell would not answer questions without protection. Markus said Maxwell has no evidence tying President Trump or former President Bill Clinton to crimes and cited a pending New York federal court petition that limits her ability to speak freely without clemency or immunity (CBS News; Politico).
“Ms. Maxwell is prepared to speak fully and honestly if granted clemency by President Trump. Only she can provide the complete account. Some may not like what they hear, but the truth matters.” — David Oscar Markus
Markus framed this as a direct appeal to the public and to the president, asserting that clemency is the only current path to full testimony.
Responses from lawmakers and staff
Republican Oversight Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.) called the refusal “very disappointing” and pledged to continue the probe with additional depositions, including a schedule naming Leslie Wexner (Feb. 18), Hillary Clinton (Feb. 26) and Bill Clinton (Feb. 27), plus depositions of Epstein’s accountant and lawyer (ABC News).
Comer and other Republicans have resisted calls to grant Maxwell immunity or encourage clemency, citing meetings with Epstein survivors who oppose leniency. Democrats criticized Maxwell’s appearance as effectively a bid for a pardon; several members accused her of protecting others rather than showing remorse (CBS News).
Legal background and prior cooperation
Maxwell is serving a 20-year sentence at a Texas prison camp following her 2021 conviction on federal sex‑trafficking charges. Prosecutors said she helped recruit, groom and abuse underage girls for Jeffrey Epstein over roughly a decade (CBS News).
Her current silence contrasts with a two-day interview she gave in July 2025 to Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, after which she was transferred to a minimum-security camp in Bryan, Texas; the Justice Department released a transcript of that interview (CBS News).
The House probe and transparency law
The deposition is part of a bipartisan investigation initiated by the House Oversight Committee after concerns about federal handling of Epstein’s case; the committee subpoenaed Maxwell in July 2025 (Politico live updates).
The probe proceeds alongside the Epstein Files Transparency Act, which President Trump signed in November 2025 mandating the Justice Department to release related files and records to the public (CBS News).
Other subpoenas and scheduled witnesses
The committee has expanded subpoenas to include former attorneys general, FBI directors, Justice Department officials, and figures tied to Epstein’s estate. Chairman Comer said further depositions may reveal how federal authorities handled Epstein and could produce new evidence (ABC News; Politico).
Legal barriers to testimony: immunity and pending petitions
Maxwell’s legal team cited a pending New York federal court petition as a key reason she refused to testify. Without either immunity from prosecution or a clemency offer removing the threat of further charges, Maxwell declined to answer questions that could be used against her in other proceedings (CBS News).
Chairman Comer has opposed immunity or recommending a pardon, pointing to survivors who view Maxwell as unrepentant; that stance limits the committee’s ability to compel testimony absent another legal avenue (ABC News).
Voices from survivors and the public
Survivors have been vocal throughout the investigation, expressing anger over perceived leniency when Maxwell was moved to a minimum-security camp after the July 2025 DOJ interview. Advocacy groups and survivors remain engaged and skeptical of any move that would grant Maxwell leniency (CBS News).
Public debate centers on whether Maxwell’s potential cooperation should be traded for legal protection. Markus’s public plea for clemency from President Trump has intensified debate about truth, accountability, and legal process.
Implications for Lake Isabella, California
Economic impact: Local law enforcement and county officials in Kern County — including Lake Isabella — may face increased inquiries from residents as national attention continues. Short-term visitor interest could boost nearby businesses, though sustained effects are unlikely (context: national reporting; see Politico; CBS News).
Political consequences: For conservative voters in Lake Isabella, the episode may reinforce calls for transparency. Local officials emphasizing law-and-order and victims’ rights can point to the House probe and the Epstein Files Transparency Act as congressional action.
Social effects: Survivors’ advocacy groups across California may renew outreach; local community organizations could host forums or town halls as residents seek information and support (CBS News).
Cultural relevance: The deposition and the clemency debate raise broader questions about institutional trust and the balance between eliciting truth and respecting legal protections. In communities like Lake Isabella, emphasis will likely remain on ensuring survivors are heard and government action is transparent.
Practical effects for residents: County officials and local law enforcement may receive requests for statements. Residents should expect ongoing national coverage and possible journalist visits; local charities and counseling services could see increased demand.
Reporting and sources
This story draws on reporting from ABC News, CBS News and Politico live updates, along with public statements by Maxwell’s attorney and House Oversight officials.
Video coverage: YouTube video (m6TY5pst7vA) and YouTube video (bhNW3AQSm4c).
Additional reporting is expected as the House Oversight Committee continues depositions and Maxwell’s legal team pursues court petitions. The committee’s work will determine whether new evidence or testimony emerges to advance the Epstein investigation and address public demands for transparency.
