Skip to content

Business and FinanceUnited States4 min read

Cracker Barrel Board: Gilbert Dávila Resigns Amid DEI Controversy

Gilbert Dávila, a DEI consultant, has resigned from Cracker Barrel's board following shareholder rejection and a heated proxy fight fueled by criticism over his background and the company's rebranding efforts.

Share

Topics

Cracker Barrel DEI Consultant Gilbert Dávila Resigns After Heated Shareholder Proxy Fight

 

Gilbert Dávila, a DEI consultant and longtime Cracker Barrel director, resigned after shareholders rejected his re-election following a heated proxy fight centered on the chain’s rebrand and strategic direction, and proxy-adviser opposition.

 

  • Shareholder rejection: Dávila lost re-election support at the annual meeting amid activist pressure and proxy-adviser recommendations.
  • Proxy advisers weighed in: ISS and Glass Lewis recommended voting against Dávila, citing governance concerns.
  • Activist influence: Investor Sardar Biglari publicly criticized the board’s strategy and rebrand while holding roughly 3% of shares.
  • Board moves forward: Cracker Barrel thanked Dávila for five years of service and will continue with a nine-member board including CEO Julie Felss Masino.

 

Key information

Resignation and vote. Gilbert Dávila, who joined Cracker Barrel’s board in 2020 and chaired its Compensation Committee, resigned after shareholders voted against his re-election at the company’s annual meeting, according to Fox Business and Boston25.

Proxy advisers. Two proxy advisory firms — ISS and Glass Lewis — recommended shareholders vote against Dávila, citing governance and oversight concerns, per reporting from Fox Business and Boston25.

Activist pressure. Activist investor Sardar Biglari led a public campaign criticizing the board’s strategic choices — from acquisitions to store openings and the rebrand — and owns about 3% of Cracker Barrel shares, according to Fox Business and Restaurant Business.

Board composition. The company thanked Dávila for five years of service and confirmed the board will move forward with nine directors — CEO Julie Felss Masino and eight other nominees — per the company statement on PR Newswire.

 

Background: Who is Gilbert Dávila and why he was targeted

Professional profile. Gilbert Dávila is president and CEO of DMI Consulting, a multicultural marketing and DEI firm. He joined Cracker Barrel’s board in 2020 and served as chair of the Compensation Committee, making him a visible voice on compensation and strategy (see Boston25 and HR Brew).

Why he drew scrutiny. Conservative critics argued that Dávila’s DEI credentials signaled a shift away from Cracker Barrel’s traditional image. Opponents blamed board decisions — including an updated logo and marketing direction — for weakening customer support and shareholder value, a theme echoed in coverage by Fox Business, HR Brew, and AOL.

 

The shareholder proxy fight: who pushed the vote and why

Biglari’s campaign. Sardar Biglari led a public campaign arguing management had lost touch with core customers by expanding in ways he opposed and by supporting the rebrand that many felt misread Cracker Barrel’s market, as reported by Fox Business and Restaurant Business.

Proxy-adviser influence. Institutional Shareholder Services and Glass Lewis recommended shareholders oppose Dávila; such guidance often sways institutional investors and can be decisive in director contests, per Fox Business and Boston25.

Voting outcome. Preliminary tallies indicated broad support for most company nominees and bylaw amendments but resistance to specific individuals highlighted by proxy advisers and activists; the board announced it will continue with a nine-member slate, according to PR Newswire.

 

Rebrand fallout and the DEI debate

Public reaction. Cracker Barrel’s new logo and marketing direction sparked a wave of conservative criticism focused on perceived changes to the chain’s identity. Critics claimed the company abandoned the look and tone familiar to long-time patrons, a backlash covered by HR Brew and AOL.

Business and cultural impact. The backlash coincided with a drop in the company’s stock performance; critics used that decline to argue management decisions — including DEI-linked initiatives — distracted from core operations and guest experience, as discussed in reporting by Fox Business and HR Brew.

 

Company response and board statement

Official statement. Cracker Barrel issued a statement thanking Dávila for five years of service, noting his role in strategic planning and compensation oversight, and said it remains focused on returning to growth while preserving its heritage (see PR Newswire).

“We thank Mr. Dávila for his service and will move forward with the board comprised of nine members, including CEO Julie Felss Masino,” the company said in its release.

 

What outside observers are saying

Analyst views. Industry and governance analysts say the episode highlights the risks when strategic shifts clash with vocal customers and shareholders. Activist campaigns and proxy-adviser recommendations can rapidly change board composition and corporate strategy, a point underscored in coverage by Restaurant Business and Fox Business.

Share

Topics

Joel Patterson

Joel Patterson is a senior business and finance analyst for Times Media Service, based in the Washington bureau. Patterson covers markets, companies, personal finance and economic policy, along with transportation and its financial and economic impacts. Patterson holds a master's degree in finance and grew up in Newcastle upon Tyne, England.

Write to Joel